History of Trash

History of Trash

History of Trash: Fond of history different to understand, let alone complete it and worthy referenced. Merely fond of history, knowingly and recklessly verdict '' wrong '' or '' wrong '', just look for cases unnecessary.In Mongondow, despite increasingly longar tradition and culture, for trouble still have consequences. If it was not slapped for being in contempt, the most minimal so the object of ridicule

I must remind Sumardi Arahbani that Mongondow humility into one expression membijaksanai problem. Humbly I've asked enlightenment associated with a very small piece of history of the Mongondow, simply because he openly accusations I manipulate my ancestral history.

I did not get any enlightenment from the forward response Arahbani Sumardi which (has kindly) delivered by someone who had the same concern to my email on Monday (February 4, 2013). I menukilkan some main points:

First, too much if called Dunnebier only works collected by fewer than four of the world's leading libraries. In Yogyakarta alone there are at least three libraries that store the works Dunnebier. Not including private collections I. Kuntara Wiryamartana, SJ, a philologist, an expert in ancient Javanese literature. My first encounter with literature about Bolaang Mongondow instead of private collections Romo Kuntara. In Jakarta, either libraries or private collections of course there is the store works Dunnebier, including the National Library. Not to mention the libraries in Europe, Australia, or America.

Secondly, it looks like Mr. Katamsi careful not to spread the cycle of history. Age Verenigde Oostindische Compaqnie (VOC) and the Dutch East Indies, it was something different.

Thirdly, something should be contemplated and rationalized with a simple historical logic; '' Has there ever been in the history of the world someone who is held captive by the enemy detained in areas or countries that are not power? "

Based on the recognition Katamsi; a contemporary of King's ancestors Abraham Sugeha (reigned 1880-1893). Remember, in times that Aceh is the country / kingdom sovereign and Aceh War (1873-1904]) raged great. Something muskhil when ancestors Katamsi discarded or imprisoned in Aceh. Instead discharged into Aceh, with the possibility of another history: it could be one of thousands of subjects who used Marsose by the Netherlands, as well as the colonial practices in the archipelago that time.

Fourth, on contract laborers, in memory of those Bolaang Mongondow could be synonymous with Java. Please read the book, Sumbangsihku For Mother Earth: set of experience and Thought (1984).

Fifth, entered the 19th century, servant-servant of North Sulawesi, Minahasa in particular, began to engage in military activities Indies. The Dutch colonial begin attracted to the soldiers Minahasa seeing Tondano prowess War (1804-1807). Since the War Tondano that the Dutch began to recruit people to serve Minahasa soldier / soldiers. Minahasa soldiers is what the Dutch used in the Java War / Diponegoro (1825-1830) and the Padri War. It is said that this Minahasa soldiers, under the leadership of Dotulong were able to offset the resistance of the people of Java. At this time, of course, the royal servant Bolaang Mongondow not been involved in military activities Indies.

Sixth, enters the second half of the 19th century, the military strength of the Dutch East Indies [KNIL] no longer simply rely on the Ambonese and Minahasa. Start-subjects recruited subjects in almost the entire royal kingdom in the archipelago to be soldiers Dutch East Indies. It has not been clearly stated their subjects swapradja Bolaang Mongondow-servant in the Colonial Army formations. For North Sulawesi, which is the subject-called subjects of Gorontalo, Sangihe and Minahasa. Yet despite Bolaang Mongondow subjects not mentioned, of course there are a few decent allegedly involved in the army Marsose / KNIL. Had Mr. Katamsi true recognition that his ancestors were contemporaries of King Abraham Sugeha been sent to Aceh; with the logic of history can be concluded he joined the army Marsose / KNIL.

Seventh, perhaps the book "Gedenkschrift Royal Netherlands Indisch Leger 1830-1950", by Van Meel P can be used as an additional collection of Mr. Katamsi. In the book I can make sure no ancestral name Pak Katamsi allegedly sent to Aceh; because the names are mentioned in the book are those of the Marsose who has a high position in the army KNIL, the majority of whom are soldiers Minahasa origin. But once again, based on the testimony spoken hereditary as Katamsi told, and is associated with historical patterns umun the Dutch East Indies, should the logic of history above should be considered: Not discarded because against the Netherlands; however included in the KNIL army formation. A lucrative career for sebagain subjects pribuma that time.

Without further ado, I will comment on one by one what the Sumardi Arahbani, to show that knowledge of history is not yet as high as her confidence. First, I do not write '' works Dunnebier '' just a book. I believe what is collected by the I Kuntara Wiryamartana, SJ is the Gospel speak Mongondow work W Dunnebier. I do not wonder when a Catholic priest has a book (especially the Gospel speaking regions) written by a Protestant minister.

While the collection of the National Library (National Archives even), many years ago I have sambangi (along Reiner Ointoe and hunch Mokodompit). As a result, much of what is known as if Sumardi Arahbani. Even the Library of Utrecht University and Leiden University are supposedly very complete collection of various books and records relating to Indonesia the past, also does not deviate complete works Dunnebier.

If you want to contend, I need to remind, it has been the last eight years of my intensive hunt Mongondow literature, including the Netherlands, as curious about the poor records about the history of this area. In summary, none of the complete library has meyimpan work W Dunnebier (if Sumardi Arahbani able to show who or where the library has a complete collection that, my joy will be visited). Moreover, the notes he made (journals and the like), which was never published openly. So, if you just read the two books of history (even just look at the collections of others and guessing collections elsewhere) and so jumawa, staunch in its historical context Mongondow, frankly I can not forgive you, Sumardi Arahbani

Secondly, you mentioned in a previous post (From War Aceh to Katamsi Ginano: Notes polemic Totabuan province), that: '' If it is true that grandfather Pak Katamsi been "placed" in Aceh; actual historical fact is he was hired by the Dutch government to quell the resistance Rakyat Aceh. So, instead of discarded as against the Netherlands.(History of Trash)

Tweet